The insurance coverage claims trade is in a continuing battle to stop policyholders and the general public from figuring out all of the unhealthy religion actions insurers do to delay, deny, and underpay claims. Like every unhealthy actor, secrecy of the wrongful motion is a core part to stop accountability. We famous this motive for secrecy in Commerce Secrets and techniques: Dynamite Discovery Choices, Half 11.
In his wonderful weblog, claims skilled Dennis Wall has been writing about wrongful claims practices secrecy. He famous a current case1 the place Oklahoma policyholders efficiently obtained standing to problem the secrecy of key paperwork and proof of unhealthy religion conduct in Trial Court docket Do Over For Sealed Paperwork In Insurance coverage Unhealthy Religion Case. He famous the significance of the case:
This ruling that nonparties to an insurance coverage unhealthy religion lawsuit have standing to claim public entry to supplies concerned in that lawsuit is doubtlessly essential to different insurance coverage unhealthy religion lawsuits in different jurisdictions during which trial courts have entered protecting orders barring disclosure of such supplies in related instances.
…
Just like the Newbys, nonparties to unhealthy religion litigation in different jurisdictions could win the battle however lose the warfare of public entry, so to talk — however the potential exists for public entry to paperwork filed in public court docket recordsdata in each case, and so it existed right here. Most significantly for different litigation, nonparties have standing to sue to require public entry in insurance coverage unhealthy religion litigation if this determination is adopted elsewhere in that regard.
The circumstances surrounding these acts led to a $25m settlement with the State of Oklahoma, as famous in Sizzling off the Press: Farmers to Pay Oklahoma Policyholders $25 Million for Earthquake Claims. Discovery in an insurance coverage unhealthy religion case is commonly a recreation “cover the proof” by the insurance coverage firm making an attempt to stop turning over the incriminating proof. If it had been a felony case somewhat than a civil matter, it will be known as “obstruction of justice.”
Thought For The Day
The best evils on the planet is not going to be carried out by males with weapons, however by males in fits sitting behind desks.
—Hannah Arendt
1 Good v. Farmers Ins. Co., 536 P.3d 961, 2023 WL 5951464 (Okla. Civ. App. Feb. 15, 2023).